Financiación autonómica y control de constitucionalidad (algunas reflexiones sobre la STC 13/2007)

dialnet-ar-18-ART0000207461

dialnet

Dialnet

Dialnet AR

Revista d'estudis autonòmics i federals, ISSN 1886-2632, Nº. 6, 2008, pags. 92-124

Spanish

principio dispositivo
control de constitucionalidad
Estatutos de Autonomía
financiación autonómica
impuestos cedidos
deuda histórica
dispositive principle
control of constitutionality
statutes of autonomy
financing system of the Autonomous Communities
ceded taxes
historical socio-economic investment's claims

principio dispositivo
control de constitucionalidad
Estatutos de Autonomía
financiación autonómica
impuestos cedidos
deuda histórica
dispositive principle
control of constitutionality
statutes of autonomy
financing system of the Autonomous Communities
ceded taxes
historical socio-economic investment's claims
Medina Guerrero, Manuel
Financiación autonómica y control de constitucionalidad (algunas reflexiones sobre la STC 13/2007)

The recently reformed statutes of autonomy have regulated with detail which are the revenue sources of their respective Autonomous Communities. However, in doing it so, the statutes do not have a complete margin of manoeuvre. In fact, according to the Spanish Constitution (article 153.3), the regulation of the exercise of the financial revenues by the Autonomous Communities and of the financial collaboration of the latter with Spanish central government's institutions corresponds to a specific Spanish law: the Organic Law on the Financing of the Autonomous Communities - Ley Orgánica de Financiación de las Comunidades Autónomas, LOFCA). Therefore, one question arises: which norm (statute or LOFCA) prevails in case of conflict. From this perspective, the author analyses a concrete case: that of the conflict between some provisions of the 2007 Andalusian statute and the LOFCA. He starts by pointing out that the 2007 statute of autonomy of Andalusia establishes that central government should grant Andalusia with complementary funds in order to balance Andalusia's historical socio-economical gap. The previous statute also referred to it and, in fact, there were some legislative developments on the issue, together with a ruling by the Constitutional Court (ruling 13/2007). Since this specific financial issue established in the 2007 Andalusian statute is not considered in the LOFCA, the above-mentioned question applies, that is, which norm, the statute or the LOFCA, does prevail. In this sense, firstly the author examines how and to which extent the Constitutional Court can control the ensemble of norms (Constitution, statutes, LOFCA) that allocate the financing powers among the different levels of government. Secondly, he critically analyses how the ruling of the Constitutional Court (13/2007) decides on the apparent contradiction between the statutes and the LOFCA on the subject, and he concludes that the 13/2007 ruling goes far beyond the literal interpretation of the norms.

Article

Medina Guerrero, Manuel

Medina Guerrero, Manuel

Medina Guerrero, Manuel

Financiación autonómica y control de constitucionalidad (algunas reflexiones sobre la STC 13/2007)

Financiación autonómica y control de constitucionalidad (algunas reflexiones sobre la STC 13/2007)

Financiación autonómica y control de constitucionalidad (algunas reflexiones sobre la STC 13/2007)

Financiación autonómica y control de constitucionalidad (algunas reflexiones sobre la STC 13/2007)

Financiación autonómica y control de constitucionalidad (algunas reflexiones sobre la STC 13/2007)

financiación autonómica y control de constitucionalidad (algunas reflexiones sobre la stc 13/2007)

Generalitat de Catalunya: Institut d'Estudis Autonòmics

2008

https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/oaiart?codigo=2602026

1709707691442569216

dialnet-ar-18-ART00002074612016-09-15Financiación autonómica y control de constitucionalidad (algunas reflexiones sobre la STC 13/2007)Medina Guerrero, Manuelprincipio dispositivocontrol de constitucionalidadEstatutos de Autonomíafinanciación autonómicaimpuestos cedidosdeuda históricadispositive principlecontrol of constitutionalitystatutes of autonomyfinancing system of the Autonomous Communitiesceded taxeshistorical socio-economic investment's claimsThe recently reformed statutes of autonomy have regulated with detail which are the revenue sources of their respective Autonomous Communities. However, in doing it so, the statutes do not have a complete margin of manoeuvre. In fact, according to the Spanish Constitution (article 153.3), the regulation of the exercise of the financial revenues by the Autonomous Communities and of the financial collaboration of the latter with Spanish central government's institutions corresponds to a specific Spanish law: the Organic Law on the Financing of the Autonomous Communities - Ley Orgánica de Financiación de las Comunidades Autónomas, LOFCA). Therefore, one question arises: which norm (statute or LOFCA) prevails in case of conflict. From this perspective, the author analyses a concrete case: that of the conflict between some provisions of the 2007 Andalusian statute and the LOFCA. He starts by pointing out that the 2007 statute of autonomy of Andalusia establishes that central government should grant Andalusia with complementary funds in order to balance Andalusia's historical socio-economical gap. The previous statute also referred to it and, in fact, there were some legislative developments on the issue, together with a ruling by the Constitutional Court (ruling 13/2007). Since this specific financial issue established in the 2007 Andalusian statute is not considered in the LOFCA, the above-mentioned question applies, that is, which norm, the statute or the LOFCA, does prevail. In this sense, firstly the author examines how and to which extent the Constitutional Court can control the ensemble of norms (Constitution, statutes, LOFCA) that allocate the financing powers among the different levels of government. Secondly, he critically analyses how the ruling of the Constitutional Court (13/2007) decides on the apparent contradiction between the statutes and the LOFCA on the subject, and he concludes that the 13/2007 ruling goes far beyond the literal interpretation of the norms.Las recientes reformas estatutarias han tendido, de una parte, a regular con mayor detalle que sus versiones iniciales el reparto de las competencias financieras y, de otro lado, han procurado subrayar el papel determinante de las respectivas CCAA en la aplicación a su territorio de nuevos modelos de financiación. El reformado marco estatutario ha supuesto, en consecuencia, el afianzamiento en la esfera hacendística del principio dispositivo, que habrá sin embargo de conciliarse con la habilitación conferida al legislador orgánico por el artículo 157.3 CE. En este contexto, no es de extrañar que la STC 13/2007 fuera recibida con cierta expectación, toda vez que estaba llamada a abordar dos situaciones que, en principio, son susceptibles de volver a plantearse tras las reformas estatutarias, a saber: la posibilidad de que una CA rehuse incorporarse a un nuevo modelo de financiación, y la eventual inaplicación de alguna medida estatutaria que, como la "deuda histórica", no parecía asumida con alcance general en la LOFCA. Pues bien, la STC 13/2007 no ha venido sino a confirmar la línea jurisprudencial preexistente, ya que mantiene la tendencia a utilizar la LOFCA como instrumento nivelador de las eventuales peculiaridades financieras que puedan incorporar los diferentes Estatutos, aun a riesgo de apurar al límite las posibilidades hermenéuticas que ofrece su tenor literal.Generalitat de Catalunya: Institut d'Estudis Autonòmics2008text (article)application/pdfhttps://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/oaiart?codigo=2602026(Revista) ISSN 1886-2632Revista d'estudis autonòmics i federals, ISSN 1886-2632, Nº. 6, 2008, pags. 92-124spaLICENCIA DE USO: Los documentos a texto completo incluidos en Dialnet son de acceso libre y propiedad de sus autores y/o editores. Por tanto, cualquier acto de reproducción, distribución, comunicación pública y/o transformación total o parcial requiere el consentimiento expreso y escrito de aquéllos. Cualquier enlace al texto completo de estos documentos deberá hacerse a través de la URL oficial de éstos en Dialnet. Más información: https://dialnet.unirioja.es/info/derechosOAI | INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS STATEMENT: Full text documents hosted by Dialnet are protected by copyright and/or related rights. This digital object is accessible without charge, but its use is subject to the licensing conditions set by its authors or editors. Unless expressly stated otherwise in the licensing conditions, you are free to linking, browsing, printing and making a copy for your own personal purposes. All other acts of reproduction and communication to the public are subject to the licensing conditions expressed by editors and authors and require consent from them. Any link to this document should be made using its official URL in Dialnet. More info: https://dialnet.unirioja.es/info/derechosOAI